PR-227 at a glance
PR-227 | |
|---|---|
Group code | PR, Patient Responsibility (X12) |
CARC 227 text (X12) | Information requested from the patient/insured/responsible party was not provided or was insufficient/incomplete. At least one Remark Code must be provided (may be comprised of either the NCPDP Reject Reason Code, or Remittance Advice Remark Code that is not an ALERT.) |
In the X12 list since | September 21, 2008. Last modified September 20, 2009 |
What it means for a therapy practice | The plan sent the client or subscriber a question, often by mail, and is holding payment until it's answered |
Who owes the balance | The client, for now. In practice it's usually payable once they respond |
Usual fix | Find out what was asked, have the client or subscriber answer it, then ask the payer to reprocess |
PR 227 denial code description, line by line
The X12 text names three people the request could have gone to: the patient, the insured and the responsible party. In a therapy practice those are often different people. A teenage client is the patient, a parent is the insured subscriber, and a divorced parent may be the responsible party for the bill. The payer may have written to someone your client never talks to.
The second sentence of the text requires the payer to send at least one remark code with CARC 227. Look for it on the same service line or at the claim level. It's your best clue to what was asked, so write it down before you call.
What the payer usually wants from the client
The X12 text doesn't say what the information is, and payers use the code for different requests. The ones a therapy practice is most likely to hear about on the phone:
- A coordination of benefits questionnaire asking whether the client has other insurance, such as a spouse's plan or a second parent's plan.
- An accident or injury questionnaire, when the diagnosis or history suggests another party could be liable.
- Proof of a dependent's status, such as student enrollment for an adult child on a parent's plan.
- An updated address or member details after mail came back undeliverable.
These are illustrations of what to ask about, not a list from X12. The payer's letter and the remark code tell you which one applies.
A worked example: a teenager on two parents' plans
An illustrative case. A fictional 15‑year‑old client, Ava, starts weekly therapy. Her mother brings her and gives the practice her plan's card. The plan sees that Ava's father is also listed as a subscriber elsewhere and mails a coordination of benefits questionnaire to the mother's address on file, which is out of date. Six weeks of claims come back PR‑227.
The practice calls the plan, learns the questionnaire was about other coverage, and gives the mother the plan's member services number. She confirms Ava has no other coverage over the phone. The practice then asks the plan to reprocess the six claims under the call reference number, and they pay.
How to fix PR-227
- Read the remark code on the remittance and call the payer. Ask exactly what was requested, from whom, when, and how it can be answered.
- Tell the client or subscriber what the payer needs and give them the number to call or the form to return. Some payers take the answer by phone.
- Once the payer confirms it has the answer, ask whether it will reprocess the claims on its own or needs a resubmission. Write down the reference number.
- If the client won't respond, bill them under your financial policy. The PR group puts the balance on them, and the remittance shows why.
PR-227 vs CO-226 and CARC 22
Code | Who the payer is waiting on | Typical therapy case |
|---|---|---|
PR-227 | The patient, insured or responsible party | The subscriber never returned a coordination of benefits questionnaire |
CO-226 | The billing or rendering provider | The practice didn't send the records the payer asked for |
CARC 22 | Another payer | The plan thinks a different plan should pay first. X12 text: "This care may be covered by another payer per coordination of benefits." |
CARC 227 and CARC 226 were added to the X12 list on the same day, September 21, 2008. There's one difference in wording beyond who was asked: the provider code also covers information "not provided timely", and the patient code doesn't. If the request went to your office, see CO-226. If the payer needs a document from you before it can decide, it's more likely to send CO-252.
Collect other‑insurance details at intake so a coordination of benefits question has an answer on file. The patient registration form and insurance verification form both have room for it. For a client whose coverage turns out to have ended, see PR-27.
Checked against the X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Code list in October 2026. CARC 227 was last modified on September 20, 2009, and nothing about it changed this year.

