PR-242 at a glance
PR-242 | |
|---|---|
Group code | PR, Patient Responsibility (X12) |
CARC 242 text (X12) | Services not provided by network/primary care providers. |
In the X12 list since | June 3, 2012. It replaced the deactivated CARC 38 |
What it means for a therapy practice | The plan covers this service only from its own network or through the client's primary care provider, and you weren't that |
Who owes the balance | The client, under their plan terms, unless the plan's decision was wrong |
Usual fix | Check network status and plan type, fix the claim if the plan has you on file wrongly, or bill the client per your financial policy |
What PR 242 means on a remittance
Every adjustment on an 835 remittance pairs a group code with a reason code. The group says who carries the amount and the reason says why. PR is Patient Responsibility. CARC 242 reads "Services not provided by network/primary care providers." Put together, PR‑242 says: the plan isn't paying because you're not in its network or not the primary care provider it requires, and the member is liable.
PR‑242 is mostly a managed care denial. Medicare's own description of Medicare Advantage HMO plans says members "generally must get your care and services from doctors, other health care providers, and hospitals in the plan's network," and that out‑of‑network care may mean paying the full cost. Commercial HMO and EPO plans work the same way.
PR 242 vs CO 242
The reason code is the same in both. The group code changes who is on the hook.
Code | Who carries the amount | Typical therapy example |
|---|---|---|
PR-242 | The client | Client with an HMO plan sees an out-of-network therapist. The plan has no out-of-network benefit |
CO-242 | The provider | You're in the network, but the plan's records list a different rendering provider or location, so the claim reads as out of network. Your contract stops you billing the client |
CO-288 | The provider, usually | The plan needed a referral on file and none was there |
CARC 288 reads "Referral absent", so that's the code for a missing referral. CARC 242 is about who gave the care. CARC 243, its sibling, reads "Services not authorized by network/primary care providers." Both 242 and 243 replaced CARC 38, which X12 stopped on January 1, 2013. Older billing guides that still describe CARC 38 are describing what is now split across these two codes.
Common reasons for PR-242 in a therapy practice
- You're out of network and the client's plan is an HMO or similar plan with no out-of-network benefit.
- You're in network with the carrier but not with this specific plan or product, for example a narrow-network exchange plan.
- The claim went out under a rendering NPI that isn't credentialed with the plan yet, such as a new associate therapist.
- The plan routes behavioral health through a separate managed behavioral health company, and you're contracted with the medical side only.
- The plan's provider directory has an old address or tax ID for you, so the claim doesn't match your contract.
The last three are fixable on your side. The first two usually aren't, and the client owes the balance.
How to fix PR-242
- Pull the plan type and network from the eligibility check. Write down the product name as well as the carrier, since one carrier can sell both HMO and PPO products.
- Confirm your status for that product and that rendering NPI. Call provider services or check the payer portal, and write down the reference number.
- If the plan has you wrong, correct it and resubmit. Ask the plan to fix its file, then send a corrected claim or a reconsideration with the contract or credentialing approval date.
- If the denial is right, bill the client per your policy. The PR group means the plan considers the member liable. Give the client the remittance details so they can see the plan's reason.
- If the client was told they had out-of-network coverage, they can appeal. The plan's appeal process belongs to the member here, though you can supply records.
Preventing PR-242 before the first session
Run the eligibility check before the intake, not after the third session. Ask the client for the plan name printed on the card, and check whether behavioral health is carved out to a different company. When you hire a new clinician, hold their insured clients until the plan confirms them as in network for that product.
For a client who chooses to see you out of network anyway, put the out‑of‑network status and their payment responsibility in writing at intake and keep the signed form in the chart. Our therapy intake assessment template has a place for it.
Related denial codes: CO-288 for a missing referral, PR-27 for coverage that had ended, PR-177 for eligibility not met, CO-256 for services not payable under a managed care contract, and CO-24 for charges covered under a capitation agreement.
Checked against the X12 Claim Adjustment Reason Code list on October 19, 2026. CARC 242 was last modified on June 2, 2013, and its text hasn't changed since.

